By using this website you agree to our Cookie policy

March 1991

Vol. 133 | No. 1056

Italian Renaissance Panel Paintings

Editorial

The Badminton Cabinet

ON 14TH FEBRUARY the National Art Collections Fund mounted a last-ditch national appeal to keep the Badminton Cabinet in Britain - the first such venture since the success- ful campaign for Leonardo's Burlington House Cartoon in 1962. By the time this issue is published the Cabinet (Fig.98 on p.221 below) will be on view in the suitably imposing surroundings of the King's Library in the British Museum. Those who never saw it either in situ at Badminton, or before its sale at Christies last July, will have a chance to judge the extraordinary scale and quality of this piece, twice the height of a man, a Gesamtkunstwerk of ebony, carved and inlaid hardstones and cast gilt-bronze sculpture.

Editorial read more
  • Paolo Uccello's 'Hunt in the Forest'

    By Martin Kemp,Ann Massing,Nicola Christie,Karin Groen

    UCCELLO's Hunt in the forest in the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford (Fig.1), is an exceptional work in a number of respects.* No picture painted in the period between 1400 and 1900 represents a more sustained attempt to subjugate a natural scene to the kind of pictorial ordering normally reserved for architectural subjects or settings. Secular, non-historical panel paintings of comparable dimensions rarely survive from the middle years of the fifteenth century, though contemporary inventories suggest that they were relatively common features in the interior decoration of Italian palaces and villas by the 1490s. As a surviving painting of a contemporary hunting scene by a major master, the Hunt has no precise parallel in the Quattrocento as a whole. Since the Ashmolean picture, which had been part of the Fox-Strangways gift in 1850, entered the Uccello canon only in 1898, and no direct documentation or early provenance is definitely known, all the main historical questions must be answered on the basis of the appearance of the picture itself. Not only has the conservation work undertaken on the Hunt by Ann Massing at the Hamilton Kerr Institute of the University of Cambridge provided new evidence about Uccello's technique (including his methods of perspectival construction), but it also presents an ideal opportunity to reassess other aspects of the form and function of Uccello's delightful masterpiece.

  • Some Problems in the Reconstruction of Uccello's 'Rout of San Romano' Cycle

    By Volker Gebhardt

    ALTHOUGH they form one of the most important painted cycles of the Florentine Quattrocento, Uccello's three panels depicting the Rout of San Romano (Figs.38, 39 and 41), remain far from comprehensively understood, and uncertainty about their original shape has resulted in several unsatisfactory attempts at reconstructing their former set- ting in the Palazzo Medici in Florence. Paul Joannides's recent Shorter Notice in this Magazine has added some useful observations, but some incorrect assumptions and preconceptions should be corrected and the physical evidence thoroughly reviewed.

  • Sano di Pietro's Bernardino Altar-Piece for the Compagnia della Vergine in Siena

    By Michael Mallory,Gaudenz Freuler

    SANO DI PIETRO's three large panel paintings depicting Bernardino of Siena preaching in the Piazza S. Francesco in Siena (Fig.54), Bernardino ascending into heaven (Fig.53), and Bernardino preaching in the Campo of Siena (Fig.55) are first listed in their present location, the chapter-house of Siena Cathedral, by Ettore Romagnoli in his guidebooks of 1836 and 1840. Since that time, attention has focused on the novel pair of preaching scenes. Dating from some time around the middle part of the fifteenth century, they have been seen as exceptional because they record actual events, and hence are of a type very rare for their time. It has also been noticed that because their renderings of the Palazzo Pubblico and church of S. Francesco are so accurate, they are vital documents for reconstructing the building his- tories of these important places. Their intended setting and function, however, have remained a mystery. Other than the fact that they are said to have come to the chapter- house from the private collection of Antonio Palmieri Nuti, their original provenance, which one might otherwise sup- pose to have been Siena Cathedral, is unknown.

  • Sir David Piper 1918-1990

    By Richard Walker

    IF EVER a man of our time was 'life-enhancing' it was David Piper, who died on 29th December 1990. As museum director, as man of letters, and as a family man and friend, Piper contributed positively and lavishly, with the same apparent insouciance that enabled him to survive jungle warfare and three years in a Japanese prison camp. He described some of this experience in an article for the Observer, 'I'm well, who are you?', curiously reprinted as a Dutch reading-book, and in a novel, Trial by Battle, both of which contain much of his personal ideals. Fellow- survivors have also described how Piper, then in his early twenties, encouraged the camp inmates with his verse, his theatrical productions, and his general air of civilised acceptance of a particularly horrendous experience.