By using this website you agree to our Cookie policy

January 1993

Vol. 135 | No. 1078

The Burlington Magazine

Editorial

Betrayal of Trust

THE proposed sale by Royal Holloway and Bedford New College of three of the most important pictures from the Founder's collection has been mentioned more than once in these pages. The sale scheme, initiated in 1987-88, received the imprimatur of the Charity Com- missioners only in May this year, and the validity of the Commissioners' decision has since been widely ques- tioned. Fears expressed early on that the Holloway in- itiative would encourage other hard-pressed educational institutions to think of selling major works have been amply borne out by events: it has recently been revealed that Edinburgh University has plans to sell items from the Torrie bequest of 1825. The Holloway and Edinburgh schemes, which both involve the breach of Wills and trusts, would, if successful, inevitably become test cases in English and Scottish law. It is therefore vital for the future integrity of university collections that the sales be averted.

Editorial read more
  • Front Matter

  • Ridolfo Ghirlandaio's Altar-Pieces for Leonardo Buonafé and the Hospital of S. Maria Nuova in Florence

    By David Franklin

    IT was rare for a single patron in renaissance Italy to com- mission a large number of altar-pieces. The Florentine, Leonardo di Giovanni Buonafe (c. 1450-1545) was respon- sible with varying degrees of personal intervention for about fifteen. This article will deal principally with the painted altar-pieces with which he was concerned as director, between 1500 and 1528, of S. Maria Nuova, the most import- ant hospital in Florence. Examination of the hospital's ledgers permits, in most cases for the first time, firm docu- mentation of eight of the ten paintings ordered for altars under the hospital's jurisdiction during his tenure. Up to now the best known of these have been the two ordered by Buonafe late in life from Ridolfo Ghirlandaio and his pupil Michele Tosini: a Virgin and Child with Sts Jacob, Francis, Claire and Lawrence, for S. Jacopo on the Via Ghibellina in Florence, and a Meeting of Joachim and Anna at the Golden Gate with Sts Joseph and Leonard, for the oratory of the SS. Concezione dei Preti (Figs.1-2). Both include a donor portrait of Buonafé in their lower left corners, and they can be dated, on the basis of new documents, to c. 1531-44.

    , for S. Jacopo on the Via Ghibellina in Florence, and a Meeting of Joachim and Anna at the Golden Gate with Sts Joseph and Leonard, for the oratory of the SS. Concezione dei Preti (Figs.1-2). Both include a donor portrait of Buonafé in their lower left corners, and they can be dated, on the basis of new documents, to c. 1531-44.

  • Piero della Francesca as Assistant to Antonio d'Anghiari in the 1430s: Some Unpublished Documents

    By James R. Banker
  • Documents for Parmigianino's 'Vision of St Jerome'

    By Mary Vaccaro

    OUR knowledge ofthe briefyet formative period Francesco Mazzola, better known as Parmigianino, spent in Rome between 1524 and 1527 relies almost entirely on the account given by Giorgio Vasari.* According to Vasari, the young artist travelled to Rome with an uncle. His presentation paintings found immediate and enthusiastic reception in the court of Clement VII, but the papal patronage he an- ticipated was not forthcoming. Nevertheless, Parmigianino managed to attract a number of more modest commissions before the Sack forced him to flee the city in 1527. In the absence of any documentation, the identification of these works and their Roman dating has been based largely on Vasari's descriptions and on stylistic evidence. The dis- covery of the contract for a major altar-piece painted by Parmigianino towards the end of his Roman sojourn - the so-called Vision of St Jerome, now in the National Gallery, London (Fig.15) - affiords the opportunity to put Vasari's authority to the test.  In addition, the documents published here expand our knowledge of the intended context and significance of Parmigianino's painting.

    , now in the National Gallery, London (Fig.15) - affiords the opportunity to put Vasari's authority to the test.  In addition, the documents published here expand our knowledge of the intended context and significance of Parmigianino's painting.

  • Parmigianino's Contract for the Caccialupi Chapel in S. Salvatore in Lauro

    By Sandro Corradini

    THE discovery of Parmigianino's contract, dated 3rd January 1526, for the Vision of St Jerome (Fig.15) now in the National Gallery in London (see the Appendix below, and Mary Vaccaro's article on p.22 above), offers an opportunity to re-examine the original context of this work in the church of S. Salvatore in Lauro.

    (Fig.15) now in the National Gallery in London (see the Appendix below, and Mary Vaccaro's article on p.22 above), offers an opportunity to re-examine the original context of this work in the church of S. Salvatore in Lauro.

  • Michelangelo in the Workshop of Domenico Ghirlandaio

    By Jean K. Cadogan

    TWO biographies of Michelangelo Buonarroti published during the artist's lifetime offier vastly diffierent accounts of his beginnings as an artist.* In 1550 Giorgio Vasari described how the artist's father Lodovico had apprenticed his son to Domenico Ghirlandaio for three years, alluding to a written agreement between the men which he had seen in Domenico's ricordi, in the possession of Domenico's son, Ridolfo. Vasari goes on to tell how Ghirlandaio recommended the young artist to Lorenzo de' Medici, who had started a school for painters and sculptors in his garden on the Piazza S. Marco.  Vasari's account of Michelangelo's apprentice- ship was firmly denied in Ascanio Condivi's biography, published in 1553. As he relates in his preface, Condivi had been a pupil of Michelangelo in Rome, had been collecting notes on the master's life and teaching for the benefit of other students, and was now publishing them - perhaps at Michelangelo's urging- to correct Vasari's account. He relates that the young Michelangelo was occasionally brought to the workshop of Ghirlandaio by Francesco Granacci, and after recounting marsy instances of Ghirlandaio's jealousy toward Michelangelo- in one instance, Ghirlandaio refused to lend him his book of drawings with 'shepherds with their sheep and dogs, landscapes, buildings, ruins, and such things' - Condivi caustically adds:

    I wanted to mention this is because I am told that Domenico's son attributes the excellence and divinitå of Michelangelo to a great extent to his father's teaching, whereas he gave him no help whatever, although Michelangelo does not complain of this; indeed he praises Domenico for both his art and his manners.

  • Lotto's 'Pietà' Altar-Piece of 1545

    By Louisa Chevalier Matthew

    THE account books of the Dominican monastery of S. Paolo in Treviso contain several payment documents which amplify our knowledge of a commission undertaken by Lorenzo Lotto in the l 540s for the nuns of that monastery.* During this decade Lotto produced approximately ten altar-pieces of various sizes and prices, some with and some without frames, for various desti- nations. The picture in question here is the Pietà now in the Pinacoteca di Brera in Milan (Fig.19), executed on canvas and supplied to the patrons without a frame.

    now in the Pinacoteca di Brera in Milan (Fig.19), executed on canvas and supplied to the patrons without a frame.

  • Artemisia Gentileschi's 'Corisca and the Satyr'

    By Mary D. Garrard

    IN the wake of the recent exhibition devoted to Artemisia Genti- leschi, which followed closely on the publication of the first monograph on her work, Artemisia's œuvre is undergoing a long overdue re-examination. New questions are being asked about received attributions and, inevitably, newly attributed paintings are surfacing. Among the latter is one that can securely be added to her œuvre, a large signed work representing a woman in a landscape running away from a seated satyr, who holds a swatch of hair in his hand (Fig.20).

    , a large signed work representing a woman in a landscape running away from a seated satyr, who holds a swatch of hair in his hand (Fig.20).

  • Carl Nordenfalk (1907-92)

    By Jonathan J. G. Alexander

    CARL NORDENFALK who died on 13thJune 1992 was a scholar of the greatest distinction who, though his main contribution to art-historical studies lay in the medieval field, also published important work on later western European painting, on Rem- brandt, on Watteau and particularly on Van Gogh. His pro- digious energy and dedication to his work is demonstrated in the list of his publications included in the Festschrift presented to him in 1987. Starting in 1931, it totals three hundred and sixty items written in German, French and English as well as his native Swedish. That was achieved in addition to his being for most of the period a museum keeper, first at Goteborg from 1935 to 1944, then at the Nationalmuseum, Stockholm, where he was in charge of Loans, Exhibitions, and Education until 1949, then of the Department of Painting and Sculpture until 1958, and finally as Director until 1968. In this post-war period he was responsible for a series of important exhibitions culminating in the Council of Europe show on Queen Christina of Sweden of 1966.

  • Back Matter

  • Visual Polemics in the Ninth-Century Byzantine Psalters

    By John Lowden
  • Piero della Francesca

    By Frank Dabell

    UP until 1984 nothing certain was known of Piero della Francesca's activity before his work in the choir of S. Egidio, the hospital church of S. Maria Nuova, Florence, in 1439.Roberto Longhi's hunch that Piero might have been apprenticed to the local master, Antonio di Giovanni from Anghiari across the Tiber Valley from Borgo San Sepolcro, has informed the prevailing view of Piero's early artistic experience. Most scholars have dismissed Antonio, assuming him to have had little talent and only a token influence on Piero's formation. Recently discovered docu- ments make it clear, however, that Piero undertook several major commissions with Antonio in and around Borgo San Sepolcro before 1438. They also indicate that for much of the 1430s Piero worked not as Antonio's apprentice but as his assistant.

  • Raphael, son atelier, ses copistes. Collection Inventaire des dessins italiens du musee du Louvre

    By Bernice F. Davidson
  • The Place of Narrative: Mural Decoration in Italian Churches, 431-1600

    By Julian Gardner
  • Les Chantiers de la Renaissance

    By Richard A. Goldthwaite