By using this website you agree to our Cookie policy

January 1994

Vol. 136 | No. 1090

The Burlington Magazine

Editorial

National Galleries and National Schools

DURING a visit to the National Gallery in London in the later 1980s, the then Prime Minister is said to have enquired with some irritation why there were not more galleries devoted to British art. Her question, ill-informed and jingoistic as it may have seemed, in fact exposed some of the problems of self-definition involved in the notions of National Galleries and national collections. These prob- lems receded in a period when internationalism or at least Europeanism was taken for granted. Now they seem to be re-emerging in the more fragmented political climate of the 1990s. What responsibilities does a National Gallery owe to its country's native artists? Should a national school be shown together with or separately from the international currents of art in which it participated?

Editorial read more
  • The Portrait of Agucchi at York Reconsidered

    By Silvia Ginzburg

    THE portrait of Giovanni Battista Agucchi in the York City Art Gallery (Fig.1), was first published by John Pope-Hennessy in 1946 as a work of Domenichino. As Pope-Hennessy pointed out, the engravings listed by Mal- vasia in his Felsina Pittrice leave no doubt as to the identity of the sitter:

    Il ritratto di Monsig. Agucchi, che in zimarra tenendo una lettera con ambe le mani, guarda noi spettatori, all'acqua forte. onc.4 onc.3 per dirit. inserito con gli altri ne gli Elogii del Tomasini; e l'istesso fatto rintagliare a bollino da un'Otteren dal Sig.Co. Valerio Zani nelle Memorie de' Signori Accademici Gelati sotto il suo Principato. onc.4 e mez. onc.3 e mez. scars.

  • The Berlin Museums after Reunification

    By Thomas W. Gaehtgens

    THE museums of Berlin are faced with their task of the century. The unification of the city has been achieved, but concomitant problems have split the museum com- munity into opposing camps. The overheated controversy that has resulted, involving a bewildering spectrum of opinions from the well-informed to the merely well-meaning, is almost impenetrable to the public, and the disputes have been unhelpfully exacerbated by a flood of announcements and of often superficial articles in the press. However, there is no doubt that extremely important issues are involved.

  • The Subject of Domenico Morone's 'Tournament' Panels in the National Gallery, London

    By Tom Henry

    TWO panels in the National Gallery, London (Figs.22 and 23), recently restored to view with the re-opening of the Lower Floor Collection, can be shown to represent the episode from ancient Roman history of the rape of the Sabine women. Both have previously been catalogued as representing a scene at a tour- nament. They are painted, probably in oil, on two horizontal planks of spruce and there is some evidence that they were originally joined.

  • Fixing Pastels: A Letter from Liotard to the 2nd Earl of Bessborough in 1763

    By Jaynie Anderson

    MUCH of the autobiographical memoir which Jean-Etienne Liotard dictated to his son concerns his relationship with William Ponsonby, the 2nd Earl of Bessborough. They met by chance in an Italian coffee house where a group of young Englishmen, in- cluding William Ponsonby, were admiring a miniature copy on ivory of the Venus de' Medici, that happened to be by Liotard. The artist announced himself with the words: 'Eh! bien, Messieurs, je m'appelle Liotard et c'est moi qui l'ai peinte'. Following a second chance meeting in 1738 Liotard accompanied 'le chevalier Ponsonby' to Constantinople, acquiring there his Turkish mannerisms, including a long beard. Liotard painted his English patron in Turkish dress, adding subsequently a pendant portrait of Lady Caroline Cavendish whom Ponsonby married in 1739.

    to Constantinople, acquiring there his Turkish mannerisms, including a long beard. Liotard painted his English patron in Turkish dress, adding subsequently a pendant portrait of Lady Caroline Cavendish whom Ponsonby married in 1739.

  • On Reynolds's Art of Borrowing: Two More Italian Sources

    By Giovanna Perini

    THE portrait of Lieutenant Colonel Tarleton (Fig.28) is one of the most popular pictures by Reynolds in the National Gallery, London. Much is known of both the sitter and the painting, which was commissioned from Reynolds and executed soon after Tarleton's return from South Carolina, where he had made a name for himself fighting for his country (and his family's business concerns) in the American War of Independence. Although the peace treaty was not signed until 1783, the long war was virtually over by January 1782, when Tarleton arrived in London, the besieged British troops having already surrend- ered at Yorktown on 19th October 1781. The painting, finished by mid-April 1782, was exhibited at the Royal Academy the following month as the 'Portrait of an Officer', in competition with yet another portrait of the same sitter by Gainsborough, now lost.

    in competition with yet another portrait of the same sitter by Gainsborough, now lost.

  • Acquisitions for the Department of Western Art in the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford, 1987-1993

    By Timothy Wilson,Catherine Whistler,Christopher White,Larissa Salmina-Haskell,Jon Whiteley,Rosemary Baird,Corinne Cherrad Marshall,Katharine Eustace