By using this website you agree to our Cookie policy

September 1999

Vol. 141 | No. 1158

The Burlington Magazine

Editorial

Lessons from Leeds

The announcement last month that the government had had to step in to avert imminent bankruptcy and perhaps closure at the new Royal Armouries museum in Leeds did not come as a great surprise to those who have followed in detail the short history of this calamitous experiment in privatisation.1 The astonishing thing is that the project was ever allowed to proceed in the first place. How can it have happened that a national trustee museum in Great Britain was actively encouraged by government to move from its historic premises in London and consign its new building to a private company on a speculative basis? The question is all the more pressing since the present government has by no means abandoned the 'Private Finance Initiative' - invented and launched by its predecessor - whereby the capital for major public projects is raised from the private sector in exchange for some form of partnership in the development.2 Moreover, in the years since the Armouries project got under- way, much quasi-public money has gone via the National Lottery to new museum projects whose viability has been premised on just the same kind of wildly unrealistic estimates of visitor figures derived from misconceived market research as were deployed during the planning of the Armouries.

 

Editorial read more
  • Artists' Inventories and the Language of the Oil Sketch

    By Linda Bauer,George Bauer

    It is a curious fact that of the hundreds of surviving oil sketches made by Peter Paul Rubens none can be recognised in the documents relating to and recording the possessions owned by the artist at his death. Any trace of these painted sketches, on which the artist placed such value, has had to be sought among the 'dessins' or 'draughts' grouped together as a single lot in the 'Specification', or catalogue of those works intended for sale after Rubens's death in 1640.1 This col- location does, however, appear consistent with Rubens's own usage in a memorandum of 1614, in which he calls one of his sketches (Fig.l) a 'dissegno colorito'.2 It also conforms to what one finds in Italy throughout the sixteenth and for much of the seventeenth centuries. Monochrome oil sketches by the Carracci (Fig. 2) are called 'disegni' by both Mancini and Malvasia;3 and in 1640 Lanfranco offered to make a 'tela ildisegno' in hopes of winning a much coveted commission.4 Such references and those to the 'disegni ad olio' found in inventories of painters' estates or mentioned in correspondence,5 all suggest that far into the seventeenth century the oil sketch had not yet acquired a name of its own but was regarded as a species of drawing. Though, as the example of Rubens shows, oil sketches were not only made but also sold, this does nevertheless suggest a certain lack of certitude about the idea of sketching in paint. The circumstances under which a clear term emerges, which is the subject of this article, may thus also be taken as marking the moment when the oil sketch acquired its own identity.

     

  • Constable and the 'Woodbridge Wits'

    By F. G. Notehelfer

    John Constable sold relatively few of his paintings during his lifetime, and though most of his major works can be traced to significant collections there is a substantial portion of his oeuvre for which there is little initial provenance. After his death in 1837, many works were disposed of at the studio sale held at Fosters the following year, catalogued with only summary descriptions and sold in bundled lots which were largely bought by dealers. There is not much information about the men and women who subsequently acquired them, who may justly be termed their original owners,' and it is worth focusing on three early collectors of his work who may well be typical of a wider range of rural collectors in the 1840s and 1850s.

     

  • Gerard David. Purity of Vision in an Age of Transition

    By Roger van Schoute,H. Verougstraete
  • Valentin Drausch und Herzog Wilhelm V. von Bayern. Ein Edelsteinschneider der Renaissance und sein Auftraggeber. (Kunstwissenschaftliche Studien, Band 75)

    By Peter Diemer,Dorothea Diemer
  • Sztuka cenniejsza niz zloto. Obrazy, rysunki i ryciny dawnych mistrzow europejskich ze zbiorow polskich. Wystawa poswiecona pamieci Jana Bialostockiego [Art More Precious Than Gold. Paintings, Drawings and Prints of Old European Masters in Polish Collections. Exhibition Dedicated to the Memory of Jan Bialostocki]

    By Katarzyna Murawska-Muthesius
  • Dulwich Picture Gallery: Complete Illustrated Catalogue

    By Alastair Laing
  • The Quest for the Grail. Arthurian Legend in British Art 1840-1920

    By Elizabeth Prettejohn
  • The Pursuit of Spiritual Wisdom: The Thought and Art of Vincent van Gogh and Paul Gauguin

    By Henri Dorra
  • American Paintings before 1945 in the Wadsworth Atheneum

    By Andrew Wilton
  • Beyond the Mainstream

    By Colin Rhodes
  • The Body/Body Problem: Selected Essays

    By David Carrier