Vol. 160 / No. 1378
Vol. 160 / No. 1378
THIS MONTH The Burlington Magazine launches an annual scholarship
for the study of French eighteenth-century fine and decorative art. Initiated
and funded by Richard Mansell-Jones, a
trustee of The Burlington Magazine Foundation, the scholarship offers £10,000 to a student based anywhere in
the world who has embarked or is about
to embark on an M.A. or Ph.D. or is undertaking research in a post-doctoral or
independent capacity. The deadline for
applications is 1st March 2018, and the successful candidate will be chosen in
April by a selection panel chaired by Christoph Vogtherr, Director of the
Hamburger Kunsthalle and former Director of the Wallace Collection, London. For
further details visit www.burlington.org.uk.
This is a propitious time to be studying French eighteenth-century
art. That may sound a surprising statement, given that the wheel of taste has
dethroned the decorative arts of the ancien régime from the supremacy they
enjoyed for nearly two centuries, ever since the Revolution provided the
material for a new, historicist enthusiasm for the country’s eighteenth-century
art by scattering its royal and aristocratic collections. To some extent, this
enthusiasm was counter-revolutionary in spirit.
When Napoleon was offered the magnificent jewel cabinet made by
Jean-Henri Riesener in 1787 for the Comtesse de Provence, sister-in-law of
Louis XVI, he rejected it as ‘du vieux’, part of the world that he had swept
away, but for that very reason it appealed to George IV, who in 1825 snapped it
up for his new apartments at Windsor Castle. The King’s appetite for French
decorative arts of all periods helped set the tone for aristocratic and
plutocratic interiors for generations to come.
At Waddesdon Manor, Buckinghamshire, in the 1880s Baron Ferdinand
Rothschild made plain the link between royal taste and ‘le goût Rothschild’ by
hanging Thomas Gainsborough’s 1784 full-length of the Prince Regent in the Red
Drawing Room.
There was nothing reactionary about that: like all his
family a Liberal in politics, Baron Ferdinand welcomed the way that, as he put
it, the Revolution had swept away ‘the rottenness and effeteness of the old order’.
The value that he and other connoisseurs of his time placed on the art of the
ancien régime while rejecting the outlook of its original patrons helped to make
the taste for eighteenth-century France acceptable to American collectors,
ranging from the Vanderbilts and Astors to J. Paul Getty.
Before the twentieth century few collectors outside France showed
a sustained interest in French eighteenth-century painting and sculpture as
opposed to decorative arts – the Rothchilds made little effort to compete with
the one great British collector in this field, the fourth Marquess of Hertford,
whose monument is the Wallace Collection. It seems likely that the growth of
enthusiasm in the twentieth century for such painters as Antoine Watteau was
part of a general revival of appreciation of eighteenth-century architecture
and design: Victorian objections to
Rococo artists as frivolous and amoral now became the basis of their
attraction.
By the late twentieth century, therefore, French eighteenth-century
art and design was understood largely in terms of the delicate eroticism of
François Boucher and Jean-Honoré Fragonard, the glamour of ormolu and porcelain
and the patronage of Madame de Pompadour or Marie-Antoinette. The fall of this taste from unchallenged
favour, thanks largely to the global
dominance of contemporary art and white-walled
minimalism in interior decoration, has arguably had a beneficial impact on the academic study of the visual
arts of eighteenth-century France since
it has helped broaden appreciation of
their many other aspects.
Some of that widening of interest has continued a
characteristically French empirical
tradition embodied in the series of monographs
published since 1978 by Arthéna, the Association pour la diffusion de l’histoire de l’art, in
which a strong emphasis on the
eighteenth century has strayed well beyond the Rococo. In addition, exhibitions in France are
challenging preconceptions that painting in this period lacks seriousness, or
is in essence secular: for example, Le baroque des Lumières. Chefs-d’oeuvre des
églises parisiennes aux XVIIIe siècle, shown last year at the Petit Palais,
Paris, assembled an impressive array of religious works.1
Research on the social history of art is also reshaping understanding
of the country’s culture in the eighteenth century. One notable manifestation
of this is Journal18, an online periodical devoted to the long eighteenth
century around the globe. Founded in 2016, and affiliated with HECAA, the
association for Historians of Eighteenth-Century Art and Architecture, and the
Institute of Fine Arts, New York, Journal18, offers an international context
for understanding French art. This sort of approach has sprung many surprises: a horse painting by Stubbs with a landscape
by Claude-Joseph Vernet and figures by François Boucher, for example, or, as an
article in this Magazine has recently demonstrated, the existence of French
Rococo architecture in Beijing.2
It would be an oversimplification to contrast this new
global approach with traditional French art history since in France the subject
has recently taken such a fruitful international turn. For instance, links
between Germany and France in the eighteenth century are among the subjects
explored by the Deutsches Forum für Kunstgeschichte (the Centre Allemand
d’Histoire de l’Art de Paris), founded in 1997 in Paris with funding from the
German ministry for research and education. One of its projects has been an analysis of the use of
the royal apartments at Versailles,3
which since 2006 has itself been home to an
academic organisation with an international reach, the Centre de recherche du château de Versailles.
Whoever is awarded The Burlington Magazine scholarship for the study of French Eighteenth-Century
fine and decorative art will take a place in a world-wide network of scholars
who are developing the subject in intriguing and often novel ways.
1 Reviewed by Humphrey Wine in this Magazine, 159 (2017),
pp.572–73.
2 D. Pullins, ‘Stubbs, Vernet & Boucher share a canvas:
workshops, authorship & the status of painting’, Journal18, 1 (Spring
2016), http://www.journal18.org/334 (accessed 11th December 2017); G.A. Bailey,
‘Rococo in eighteenth-century Beijing: ornament prints and the design of the
European palaces at Yuanming Yuan’, The Burlington Magazine, 159 (2017),
pp.778–88.
3 T.W. Gaehtgens, M.A. Castor, F. Bussmann and C. Henry, eds.: Versailles et l’Europe: L’appartement monarchique et princier, architecture, décor, cérémonial (Paris and Heidelberg, 2017).